what size barrel

[tbing13]

what size barrel do u hunt with??? what difference is there between the 26 and 28.

[Adam Barkoskie]

From what I know if it's a Shotgun a 26' Barrell will not hol a pattern as far as the 28" barrell would. But if your talking about rifles then ignore this reply.

*Adam Barkoskie-CwbyUp385@yahoo.com*

[tbing13]

i am using a over under for bird hunting..

[Adam Barkoskie]

I Wolud still say the same thing for your over and under.

[birddog]

I'm partial to longer barrels myself .. there are plenty of opinions and view points on this one .. expect to get a large range of answers.

[Reiter]

The major factors to determine the pattern are: the Choke, the pellets velocity and the shot size.
For 12 ga. 2 3/4, barrel lenghts between 24" and 32" has no efect on the pattern.

[Jim Willson]

The differnce between the 26' & 28' is a slite difference in felt recoil and patterning at distances greater then twenty five yards. Pending the choke selection.

[Graybeard]

Really a very personal matter of feel as to what works best for each of us. I personally prefer 28" barrels on doubles whether SxS or O/U on a hunting gun. For clays even longer is fine. For a pump or semiatuo I use both 26" and 28" and have no real preference unless I'm in tight quarters. For crow hunting where I might be hiding in thick tangles I like a barrel as short as 22" to 23" even.

[yankeejim]

Actually, the only difference in the two barrel lengths is how the shooter likes the weight, balance & swinging ability of the shotgun. Any shotgun expert will tell you that the difference in the two barrel lengths has absolutely no discernible effect on the pattern or effective range of the gun.
Cheers,
YJ

[fezman]

2 inches closer

[birddog]

Originally posted by yankeejim:
Actually, the only difference in the two barrel lengths is how the shooter likes the weight, balance & swinging ability of the shotgun. Any shotgun expert will tell you that the difference in the two barrel lengths has absolutely no discernible effect on the pattern or effective range of the gun.
Cheers,
YJ need to re-evaluate your definition of a shot gun expert..

It does, in fact, make a difference.

[timb99]

All things being equal, barrel length has virtually no effect on pattern, so what yankeejim said is generally accepted as accurate. If there is any effect, it's so insignificant as to be ignored.

Since virtually all the powder in a shotgun shell is burned in the first 16-17 inches of the barrel, muzzle velocity is not higher in a long barrel than in a short barrel (this is not true for rifles where barrel length DOES affect muzzle velocity.)

That being said, all things are not equal. Lots of things affect pattern.

Different barrels of the same length, made in the same factory on two different machines, or the same gun with two different brands of choke tubes, will affect patterns.

Different shell loads will affect patterns. Different shot size will affect patterns. Different shot material (chilled lead, magnum lead, steel, bismuth, hevi-shot, etc.) will affect patterns.

I reload, so I know, different brands of powder will affect patterns.

The best way to determine how your gun patterns with different combinations is to go to a pattern board.

If you have exactly the same gun with exactly the same barrel, but one is 2 inches longer, there should be no discernible difference in the pattern.

To answer the original question, in my opinion (I do not purport myself to be an expert on anything)barrel length is a matter of personal taste.

[ 02-05-2005, 02:25 PM: Message edited by: timb99 ]

[KEN]

I had the chance to buy a FAIR 16 ga with a 25" barrel. It weight about 6 lb's. Sweet gun! It had fixed chokes so I didnt buy it. I'm not about to spend 2 grand on a gun then another 5 or 6 hundred to get tubes insalled and extra tubes.

But anyway I think a light gun with shot barrels are great for Grouse hunting.

[rubicon]

I hunt grouse and woodcock in the UP....that's the Upper Peninsula in Mich....I like my 24" barrel because its easier to swing quick for snap shots.....

[The_Gun_Guy]

Depends what your hunting for
for turkeys use a 21-24"- because you need too be able handle it easier without bumping anything.
for Upland game use a long barrel 26 rec.
because your just neandering along no neep for compact
for duck it's right in the middle 23-26" barrel depending on what you prefer

[benelli duck killer]

ok..... lemme set this straight for all u newbies, the difference between a 26 nd a 28 inch barrel is a 26 inch barrel will have a bigger shot pattern/spread, a 28 inch barrel will have a small shot pattern/spread, by those 2 inches of the barrel.

that goes for all types of shotguns, oh nd it depend on the choke u use too, if it is M IC F or w/e the symbols are for the chokes

[The_Gun_Guy]

tucker:

I leave the honers to you.

[tucker301]

He'll be OK once he's sobered up.

[birddog]

Originally posted by timb99:
All things being equal, barrel length has virtually no effect on pattern, so what yankeejim said is generally accepted as accurate. If there is any effect, it's so insignificant as to be ignored.

Since virtually all the powder in a shotgun shell is burned in the first 16-17 inches of the barrel, muzzle velocity is not higher in a long barrel than in a short barrel (this is not true for rifles where barrel length DOES affect muzzle velocity.)

That being said, all things are not equal. Lots of things affect pattern.

Different barrels of the same length, made in the same factory on two different machines, or the same gun with two different brands of choke tubes, will affect patterns.

Different shell loads will affect patterns. Different shot size will affect patterns. Different shot material (chilled lead, magnum lead, steel, bismuth, hevi-shot, etc.) will affect patterns.

I reload, so I know, different brands of powder will affect patterns.

The best way to determine how your gun patterns with different combinations is to go to a pattern board.

If you have exactly the same gun with exactly the same barrel, but one is 2 inches longer, there should be no discernible difference in the pattern.

To answer the original question, in my opinion (I do not purport myself to be an expert on anything)barrel length is a matter of personal taste. few things to say to this being a reloader myself ...

burn rates, volume, gas expansion ... geesh .. unburned powder is still a relevant fact in todays recepies...



Originally posted by benelli duck killer:
ok..... lemme set this straight for all u newbies, the difference between a 26 nd a 28 inch barrel is a 26 inch barrel will have a bigger shot pattern/spread, a 28 inch barrel will have a small shot pattern/spread, by those 2 inches of the barrel.

that goes for all types of shotguns, oh nd it depend on the choke u use too, if it is M IC F or w/e the symbols are for the chokes WOW.. :cool:

[tucker301]

He is a 17 year old who found his way into Papa's liquor cabinet and then somehow managed to get on the net and into this forum.

[FN_FAL]

Once again I log onto the Benelli forum and laugh out loud thanks to tucker301. tucker301 you may want to consider stand up.

[benelli duck killer]

hey all u wanksters lol.....um i can out drink an alcoholic, so stfu, nd ah....i can out shoot u all anyday.....u come to my neck of the woods nd ill prove it to yah. nd i know what im talking bout, it doesnt matter that im 17, its my skillz i have, that own u all..... dont hate the player hate the game

[benneli duck killer]

an anudder thing,
yuo've hear of ingrowned toenails, right?

well, i got a ingrown peepee

[sdkidaho]

When I asked the question about barrel length I was directed to this article:

http://espn.go.com/outdoors/hunting/s/h_fea_02_long_and_short_F&HN.html

Thanks Tucker.

[Butch-M]

Cutting through the falderal ... Short=quicker ... long=steadier swing. Right?!

[tucker301]

That's pretty much it, Butch.

[quarrles]

The question was about upland hunting, right?
I like my Quail shot with a 26-28 barrel. Same for my pheasants. My Geese and ducks prefer a longer barrel though. I never had a chance to ask them why.

Quarrles

[split arrow]

there is no difference in what a pattern would look like when using the same chokes. a longer barrel makes it seem like the target is closer. The difference is if your hunting in tight woods you might want a shorter barrel. If i knew how to set up a link, I would give you to americangundog.com and have you look at the Shootin Straicht tips.